Busy night market where players trade gear

Economy ·

Auction house in an idle MMO: price without losing money

Listing at 12 coins doesn't earn you 12. A worked example of fees, buy orders and small-sale rounding from the Caelwatch market, plus a pricing formula.

Dark worn leather

You list 100 oak logs at 12 coins. All of them sell. You get 1,110 coins, not 1,200, and 11.1 per log may be below what your time was worth.

This guide shows where the difference goes and how to price for it. The rules are from Caelwatch, the browser idle MMO I'm building, but the maths works for any market with a listing fee and a sales tax.

How this market works

It's a commodity market, not bidding. Each listing has one price per unit and there are no bids. Anyone can buy part of a listing. You can see groups such as "from 12 each · 7 listings · 240 total", sorted from cheapest.

  • Listing durations: 1, 3 or 7 days
  • Up to 20 active listings and 20 buy orders
  • No NPC shops, and items can't be sold to the system
  • Purchases and proceeds arrive by mail

The two fees

Fee How much When Refunded?
Listing fee 2.5% of full listing value, rounded up Up front Never
Sales fee 5% of each sale, rounded up Taken from proceeds No

For the 100 logs at 12:

  • Listing value: 1,200. Listing fee: 30, paid now.
  • One buyer takes all 100: 1,200 minus a 60 fee = 1,140 by mail.
  • Net: 1,140 − 30 = 1,110, which is 7.5% off.

A hidden cost: small sales

The sales fee rounds up on each purchase. A buyer who takes 7 logs at 12 pays 84, and your fee is 5 coins (4.2 rounded up). That's about 6%, not 5%. At low prices this adds up: one log at 12 coins pays a 1-coin fee, or 8.3%. It makes little difference at high prices. If you're selling cheap materials in small amounts, add a coin of margin.

Your floor price

To keep at least X coins per unit, list at:

price = X ÷ 0.925, rounded up

So to keep 11, list at 12. To keep 100, list at 109.

Pulling a listing returns the unsold items, but the listing fee is gone. Reprice too often and those 30 coins start repeating.

Buy orders: the other side

A buy order says "I'll buy 100 oak logs at 12". The coins go in up front, plus the same 2.5% fee: 1,230 total in this case. When you create it:

  • it immediately takes all existing listings at or below your price
  • the remainder waits, and a seller can fill it with one button
  • sellers' goods go to the highest order, and they can't pick a lower one
  • an expired or cancelled order refunds unspent coins, but not the fee

So there are two prices on any item screen: "buying at 12 · selling at 14". The gap is your choice. Sell to an order right now for less, or list and wait for more.

Why anyone buys at all

With no NPC shops, the key question is what removes items. Here one thing removes items, and one more makes people buy.

Gear wears out. Worn items lose 5% durability per hour of combat. A repair costs 2 coins × tier per 1%, and half of what was repaired comes off the item's maximum forever. So a piece lasts about 40 hours of fighting, and its repairs over that life cost about 400 × tier coins. A listed item keeps its reduced maximum, so check it before buying used gear.

Time is the real price. By the game's own scripted estimate, not real players, one player alone needs about 43 hours of activity for a first T4 sword. With the market it's 27 to 31 hours. That gap is what buyers pay for and what sellers earn.

First own item at tier T2 T3 T4 T5
Solo, hours 1.5 11.4 43.1 116
With market, hours 0.6–0.8 7.8–9.3 27–31 59–75

Crafting also has a coin tax for gear and tools at T2 and up: 5, 20, 50 or 100 coins per 8 materials by tier. A T5 sword with 24 materials pays 300. Include that in your floor price.

A simple routine

  1. Open the item's group and read both prices.
  2. Work out X, what you want to keep per unit: materials, tax, your time. Your listing floor is X ÷ 0.925.
  3. Is the top buy order above X ÷ 0.95? Sell now: there's no listing fee on that sale.
  4. If not, list slightly under the cheapest seller, for 3 or 7 days, not 1, so you pay fewer listing fees.

One caveat about my own game: the rules were tuned on a 500-bot economy simulation, not real traders, and the game is new. Expect real prices to surprise us both.

Related: what happens to your loot while you're away and five questions that test any idle MMO's economy.

Look at the Caelwatch market

Numbers are Caelwatch game data at the time of writing, 9 Nov 2026. Many are drafts and may change.

  • idle mmo
  • auction house
  • economy
  • guide